
In July 2022, Tobi Lütke told Shopify’s employees that he’d bet the pandemic surge in online shopping would last, and that it hadn’t. “Ultimately, placing this bet was my call to make and I got this wrong.” Then he cut about 10 percent of its global staff, which amounts to approximately 1,000 employees. (slashdotbetakit (opens in a new tab))
Layoffs are never good news, and that sentence didn’t make them good. But it did something else. It told every manager at Shopify that “I got this wrong” is a sentence you can say at this company and still have a job. The CEO had just said it, in writing, under his own name.
That’s the trade. A leader who admits a mistake in public spends a little status and buys permission for everyone below them. The question is whether they’re willing to make that trade, or whether they keep the safety for themselves and make everyone else pretend. Most organizations treat mistakes like contraband. You can have them, but you can’t show them. Everyone knows what’s broken. Nobody says it out loud. The information exists; it just can’t travel upward. Leaders wonder why they’re always the last to know. This is why. The cost of admitting a mistake isn’t fixed. Whoever goes first sets it.
When Howard Schultz came back to Starbucks in 2008, he didn’t open with a memo about renewed focus. Starbucks closed all 7,100 of its company-owned U.S. stores for three hours to retrain 135,000 baristas, with a note on every locked door. Closing every store in the country is about as public as an admission gets. It said the company had stopped doing the basic thing well, and it said so in front of every customer. After that, it’s hard for a regional manager to be punished for saying “our execution isn’t working.” The boss already said it on the door. (Time (opens in a new tab))
This isn’t vulnerability theater. Each public admission sets the exchange rate between honesty and safety. If the leader can say “I got this wrong” and keep their authority, the manager below them can say it and keep their job. If the leader can’t, neither can anyone else. People learn what things cost and act accordingly.
The pattern runs all the way down. The executive who says “we misread the market” makes it cheaper for the director to say “we built the wrong thing.” The director makes it cheaper for the manager to say “this feature isn’t working.” The manager makes it cheaper for the engineer to say “I don’t think this approach will work.” Each admission lowers the cost of the next one. Each silence raises it.
The alternative is a company where mistakes are private and corrections are public. The direction changes and nobody explains why the old one failed. The team is left to reverse-engineer what went wrong from the change in course. That protects the leader’s image. It doesn’t teach the organization anything. From the outside, the expensive version looks stable. Nobody admits failure, so everything must be fine.
The cheap version looks messier, because people keep saying what’s broken. But the expensive version is the one that crashes without warning, because the information that could have prevented the crash never reached anyone who could act on it. Every leader is setting this price, whether they mean to or not.
It gets set each time they decide what to say in public about what went wrong.